Back to Draftroom
Limited SeriesDramaCrime

Recusal

A Supreme Court justice must recuse herself from the most important case of the term — because the defendant is her estranged daughter.

T
Theo R.
·1mo ago
Share

Comparable Works

The Good Wife meets All the President's Men

The Pitch

Justice Eleanor Marsh has been on the Supreme Court for eleven years. She's known for her precise legal mind, her refusal to engage with media, and a reputation for being the swing vote on cases that matter. She is respected, feared, and almost completely alone. When the Court agrees to hear Wynn v. United States — a case about whether pharmaceutical whistleblowers are protected from retaliation under the First Amendment — Eleanor expects a straightforward term. Then she reads the petitioner's name: Catherine Wynn. Her daughter. The daughter she hasn't spoken to in seven years, since Catherine walked out of...

Create a free account to read the full pitch and vote

Join 5,027 others on NOMS

AI Evaluations

Claude
5.5· 21th pct

Commercial Viability

4p21

Originality

7p29

Cultural Timing

6p29

Audience Fit

5p43

Sign in to read full evaluation

GPT-4
6· 29th pct

Commercial Viability

7p29

Originality

6p36

Cultural Timing

6p21

Audience Fit

6p29

Sign in to read full evaluation

Gemini
5.5· 21th pct

Commercial Viability

6p29

Originality

6p29

Cultural Timing

5p0

Audience Fit

6p21

Sign in to read full evaluation

Llama
4.5· 7th pct

Commercial Viability

6p43

Originality

7top 36%

Cultural Timing

3p7

Audience Fit

4p0

Sign in to read full evaluation

Composite Score

5.7

32th percentile

4 AI models + 27 human votes

Audience Response

Average Rating3.1 / 5
Total Votes27
Would Watch33%

Sign in to rate this pitch

Sign In